Judge Jefferson Griffin and another judge ruled that a mother could lose parental rights because she committed a crime while pregnant.
A North Carolina judge who ruled that a mother could lose her parental rights because she committed a serious crime while pregnant is running for the state’s highest court.
Judge Jefferson Griffin was part of a three-judge panel of the state court of appeals that ruled unanimously last month that a Durham woman could lose custody of her youngest child because she was pregnant with her at the time she was convicted of abusing another child.
State law allows for the termination of parental rights when a serious assault is committed against a child in the household. But Griffin and the judge who wrote the decision, Judge Hunter Murphy, ruled that this also applies to children in utero because, they said, “life begins at conception.”
(The third judge on the panel, a Democrat, agreed with the decision to remove custody, but did not support the reasoning.)
The ruling sparked widespread criticism from legal experts who pointed out the dangerous precedent such reasoning would establish.
“Imagine putting a mother in jail because authorities determined that, over the course of her pregnancy, she should have exercised more, drank less coffee and taken more prenatal vitamins,” NC Newsline wrote about the case.
Griffin is running for the NC Supreme Court seat currently held by Justice Allison Riggs, a Democrat whom Gov. Roy Cooper appointed this year when Justice Michael Morgan said he would run for governor instead of re-election.
Ruling is withdrawn after backlash
Judges Griffin and Murphy based their reasoning on a 1949 NC Supreme Court ruling that an “unborn infant” had the same rights to inherit their parents’ property as their older siblings.
“Biologically speaking, the life of a human being begins at the moment of conception,” that court ruled.
But that ruling also made it very clear that this standard applied only to property rights and inheritance.
“Ordinarily a different rule or definition is applied as to when life begins, in tort actions and in criminal statutes.”
Judges Griffin and Hunter ignored or missed that part, advocates said.
The “life begins at conception” argument is a favorite of anti-abortion rights groups, including many who are seeking to ban abortion entirely in the state. It is likely that the state supreme court, which has a 5-2 Republican majority at the moment, will hear an abortion case of some kind over the next eight years.
On November 10, after three weeks of heavy criticism, Griffin and the other two judges withdrew their ruling.
It is unclear if or when they will issue a new ruling.
Support Our Cause
Thank you for taking the time to read our work. Before you go, we hope you'll consider supporting our values-driven journalism, which has always strived to make clear what's really at stake for North Carolinians and our future.
Since day one, our goal here at Cardinal & Pine has always been to empower people across the state with fact-based news and information. We believe that when people are armed with knowledge about what's happening in their local, state, and federal governments—including who is working on their behalf and who is actively trying to block efforts aimed at improving the daily lives of North Carolina families—they will be inspired to become civically engaged.
Mark Robinson was a porn shop regular in the 90s, former store employees say
Former workers at a series of porn shops in the Greensboro area say Republican gubernatorial candidate Mark Robinson visited their stores up to five...
Opinion: Why the NC Supreme Court race might be the most important election for NC’s future
With a groundbreaking presidential ticket and a highly competitive governor’s race, it’s understandable if you haven’t been paying attention to...
Opinion: Mark Robinson wants to take away our rights and freedoms
A North Carolina woman says Mark Robinson's latest ad is trying to soften his stance on abortion rights, but she says he's an extremist who would...
Op-Ed: This November, we decide what is best for our families, and we won’t go back.
This week, I’m in Chicago for the Democratic National Convention, and I’m here for the Kamalanomenon. When Vice President Kamala Harris became the...
Josh Stein: Bringing about the end of the fentanyl crisis in our lifetime
I first met Debbie after she experienced one of the most terrible tragedies a parent can face. Her son, Hunter, was one of those larger-than-life...
Speaking in Raleigh, Kamala Harris unveils new plans to lower housing, food, and childcare costs
In the vice president’s eighth visit of the year to North Carolina this year, VP Kamala Harris proposed plans to build three million new homes, help...
Jeff Jackson on what he’d do as NC attorney general
The next attorney general will play a huge role in shaping the direction of North Carolina. In an interview, Democrat Jeff Jackson explains how his...
Get nostalgic at North Carolina’s old-fashioned soda fountains
Old-fashioned soda fountains are a thing of the past, but some North Carolina establishments are still operating well into the new millennium. When...
The Cardinal & Pine Holiday Bucket List
We’ve somehow already reached the end of another year, one that gave North Carolinians much to consider—the legalization of sports betting,...
Mark Robinson was a porn shop regular in the 90s, former store employees say
Former workers at a series of porn shops in the Greensboro area say Republican gubernatorial candidate Mark Robinson visited their stores up to five...
Opinion: Why the NC Supreme Court race might be the most important election for NC’s future
With a groundbreaking presidential ticket and a highly competitive governor’s race, it’s understandable if you haven’t been paying attention to...
Opinion: Mark Robinson wants to take away our rights and freedoms
A North Carolina woman says Mark Robinson's latest ad is trying to soften his stance on abortion rights, but she says he's an extremist who would...
Op-Ed: This November, we decide what is best for our families, and we won’t go back.
This week, I’m in Chicago for the Democratic National Convention, and I’m here for the Kamalanomenon. When Vice President Kamala Harris became the...
Josh Stein: Bringing about the end of the fentanyl crisis in our lifetime
I first met Debbie after she experienced one of the most terrible tragedies a parent can face. Her son, Hunter, was one of those larger-than-life...
Speaking in Raleigh, Kamala Harris unveils new plans to lower housing, food, and childcare costs
In the vice president’s eighth visit of the year to North Carolina this year, VP Kamala Harris proposed plans to build three million new homes, help...
Jeff Jackson on what he’d do as NC attorney general
The next attorney general will play a huge role in shaping the direction of North Carolina. In an interview, Democrat Jeff Jackson explains how his...
The Cardinal & Pine Holiday Food Guide
Struggling to put together a spread for your holiday gatherings? We’ve got you covered. North Carolina is a state of grand fortune, with scores of...
The Cardinal & Pine Holiday Shopping Guide
The holiday rush is on here in North Carolina. To take the stress out of last-minute holiday shopping, we put together a guide to our favorite...